iVillage GardenWeb iVillage GardenWeb THE INTERNET'S GARDEN & HOME COMMUNITY ADVERTISEMENT
Blogs Forums Photo Galleries Ask The Experts Tools & Directories        
Return to the Metro NY Gardening Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Community Garden Shuts Out Members

Posted by patois 6 (My Page) on
Fri, Dec 18, 09 at 16:05

I am beyond frustrated, any advice would be greatly appreciated.
Warning: This saga is rather lengthy and I am glad to have somewhere to vent.
I am new to our community (East Harlem) and started out by joining the local community garden. It was HEAVAN! My infant in the stroller, my toddler playing with trucks in the dirt and me pulling weeds, picking up trash, just keeping busy outdoors.

We moved from a house in the suburbs and I was more than happy to donate all of our old gardening supplies...mower, weed trimmer, tools, kids toys, furniture. I even bought new kids picnic benches. They were thrilled. I helped at their fleamarket, I painted a sign for it. I was the only one to contribute to the BBQ party (so they told me).

All was going well until...
The founders grown son began complaining about his aunt, another founder not letting him attend meetings and not letting him have any input. I listened and said, "Let's try to work together and try to make some changes to improve this place!"

The next time I visited the garden there was some animosity, they didn't talk to me very kindly, it was strange. I really thought nothing of it, besides someone having a bad day. The next time I went to the garden the locks were changed!

I contacted the founders, they told me,
"My son says you want to take over the garden and kick us out."
I told them that it couldn't be further from the truth,
"I think he misunderstood what I said!"
"Are you calling my son a liar?"
WHAT?

I am needless to say heartbroken about this situation. I am contacting the community garden organizers, the city, the parks department to see if I can get back into the garden.

The founders told me that I can go in when they are there, if kids want to have a place to play in go to the playground. They told me that I shouldn't start any static with them, because there have been things missing from the garden and they should be the only ones to have keys to the space. I told them that I put things in I don't take things out! They won't budge.

They act like this is their private space and hire it out for private parties and keep the money and hire someone to mow the lawn. I would mow the lawn for free!

I have talked to other people in the neighborhood who say the same thing happened to people they know. The garden founders act like they want new members but only to prove to the community garden organizers that they are accepting new members and as soon as the new members show some initiative or suggest ideas, they are shut out, and the locks are changed.

My husband asks why do I want to continue to be involved in a place like that? I think that someone needs to stand up to these people. The city created these spaces for everyone who is interested in gardening. They don't own the space...it is a community garden for the COMMUNITY!

Besides, they would not want to go and open the space for me during the early hours that I am available and they don't really adhere to the open hours that they have posted. I don't know if I am fighting a loosing battle and if this is something better left alone. But every time I walk by this place I see it's potential to be something great for children and everyone in the neighborhood and I want to be let back in!

SIGH...thanks for reading this.

Thanks for any input on this matter. I will post any information about this situation as soon as I find out more.

Here is a link that might be useful: Garden name and location


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Community Garden Shuts Out Members

Wow that's heartbreaking... but not surprising. I would tend to agree with your husband: if they are like that, there might not be any winning. Sounds like the worst of it is that you were totally manipulated by that blank-itty blank blank son.
My advice: take the high road... start a rooftop garden or a patio container garden on the grounds of your own building (I've got over a hundred varieties in mine) and just go and enjoy the community garden during the open hours. Don't give them a thing more, not even an ounce of your anger. They'll miss your contributions soon enough and maybe learn a lesson if you show yourselves bigger than they are.
Good luck. If you want to start a small garden of your own in the springtime, this is the perfect time to start wintersowing (check out the wintersowing forum here) and also keep your eyes peeled for plant trades coming up in the city this spring.
All the best,
George


 o
RE: Community Garden Shuts Out Members

This is a sad story because you were exactly the kind of member a community garden claims they wish to attract! Somebody looking to enjoy green space in an urban city who is seeking true "community", following through with the promise to join the community and contribute. Unfortunately what you encountered is something I have found at seriously, 99% of supposedly altruistic, nonprofit organizations. Big personalities and lots of politics with founders who act like CEO's of a private corporation. I'm a new mom too and know how lifesaving it is to have outdoor space for you and your child. I disagree with the other person. Think of other moms who come along and have to deal with these garden "owners" as they see themselves. I say do not just walk away without at least blowing the whistle. That's a problem when people run a community garden that's on land owned by the city that was loaned to the founders not purchased by them, as their own private club. So bust them. Find out which person in the NY State and NYC government offices oversees community gardens and write a letter describing what transpired here. Say you've heard it has happened to others. You could also write a piece about the garden for whatever blog is most popular in Harlem. Good luck.


 o
RE: Community Garden Shuts Out Members

I don't know that much about how community gardens operate, but don't they get something from ur local government e.i land or funding? Find out who oversees local community gardens and complain. I think its bull when people start acting like jerks just because they have a little power.

Don't even go through the founders, go over their heads.


 
 

 

 


Click here to learn more about in-text links on this page.



iVillage GardenWeb: The Internet's Garden & Home Community  
  iVillage Home & Garden Network